close
close

Twitch is a platform for anti-Semitism and Israel hatred

Twitch is a platform for anti-Semitism and Israel hatred

The Twitch streaming platform is changing at every turn looked by more people than any TV news network. 21.4 billion hours of content are consumed on Twitch every year. And this also applies to the anti-Semitism that the platform increasingly broadcasts in the minds of its viewers.

Despite claims from Twitch to the contrary, users in Israel and Palestine were unable to join the platform for more than a year following the Hamas attack on Israel on October 7, 2023.

If you’re older than a millennial, you’ve probably never heard of Twitch, now owned by Amazon. Three quarters of users are younger than 35 years old. Twitch started in 2011 as a platform primarily for streaming games, and today more than seven million people create Twitch content – ​​ranging from gaming to comedy and, increasingly, videos that are anti-Jewish and pro- be terror.

Hasan Piker is one of Twitch’s most popular and highest-earning creators — who is also responsible for some of the platform’s most virulent anti-Jewish content. Getty Images for Politicon

It is a powerful and seemingly dangerous platform to reach young minds.

On October 7, 2023, Hamas terrorists and thousands of Gaza residents invaded Israel, causing the worst mass murder of Jews since the Holocaust. Less than a week later, as Israelis were still trying to identify the charred remains of innocents burned alive, the streaming platform Twitch appeared to side with . . . the terrorists. Changes to Twitch coding made it nearly impossible for Israelis to join the platform.

California Governor Newsom has the power to investigate Twitch for violating the state’s anti-BDS laws. AP

This was first brought to light last May by an Israeli streamer called ‘Force’ posted on

Despite public outcry, Twitch took no action.

About a week ago, a subreddit thread also noticed the login issue. Then it snowed. One user posted: “Israel here! I just checked and indeed found myself forbidden of creating new accounts.”

Twitch denied trying to prevent users in Israel from joining the platform after October. 7. She instead posted a claim against X who registers from Israel via email were suspended after the Hamas attack to prevent violent content from being broadcast. claimed Twitch that registers via mobile phones were still allowed.

A screenshot shows the “error message” that Israeli/Palestine-based users received when they tried to log into the platform via email. @Forceultraomega/X

But according to a report from Ynet, Israel’s largest media outlet, Israelis were reportedly blocked when they tried to do so register via both email and mobile devices starting October 20 – more than a year after the Hamas massacre. Discussions on Reddit by Twitch users support Ynet’s claims. Yet it was only last month that Twitch finally addressed and corrected the login blocks, following strong public outcry.

Even worse is who and what Twitch is allowed on its platform. Like another Redditer posted“They literally have streamers celebrating terrorism against Jews.”

Twitch CEO Dan Clancy has apologized for Twitch’s Israeli snafu – and insisted that Israel/Palestine-based users can access the platform. But he must face the consequences for his company’s malfeasance, including resigning from his position. Getty Images

One of those streamers is Hasan Piker, my organization StopAntisemitism named our anti-Semite of the week in April – and who in 2019 said that “America deserved 9/11, dude. Fk it, I’m saying it.

More recently, Piker declared there was no evidence of mass rape or murder by Hamas last October. Although the terror group livestreamed their bloody plunder of Israel, Piker hosted flow where he refused or rejected Hamas’s sexual violence goes so far as to say, “It doesn’t matter if the rapes took place on October 7.”

This type of content is against the Twitch community guidelineswhich states: “Twitch does not allow content that depicts, glorifies, encourages, or supports terrorism or violent extremist actors or acts.”

Twitch “Trust & Safety” team member Fadzai Madzingira, who was hired by Twitch even though she was on leave from her previous job due to alleged anti-Israel bias.
LinkedIn

While Piker faced a temporary situation delay in 2021 for using the word “cracker” to describe white people, he said reportedly earns millions annually from the platform. He is so loved by Twitch that CEO Dan Clancy and Twitch employees celebrated the streamer’s birthday in July by singing live for him. Despite this outrage, Twitch has ignored the more than 7,000 complaints our organization sent to them about Piker’s behavior.

It’s not just Twitch users who traffic in hate, employees do it too. For example, the company’s Trust & Safety team includes Fadzai Madzingira, who was suspended from a job at Ofcom, Britain’s independent communications regulator, because of her alleged anti-Israel bias. On October 16, 2023, when Israel had not yet responded to the massacre, Madzingira reportedly accused Israel on an Instagram page of “ethnic cleansing and genocide of the Palestinians.” after; Still, Twitch found her worthy of a job.

What is the answer to all this? CEO Daniel Clancy must answer for Twitch’s treatment of Israeli users and resign. The way he runs Twitch – with its unethical boycott of Israel and the persistent anti-Semitic, pro-terror voices that flourish there – is deeply disturbing.

According to a Twitch spokesperson in response to questions from the Post: “There is no place on Twitch for hate or harassment of any kind, including anti-Semitism and Islamophobia. Twitch is and always will be about belonging. We have clear community guidelines that prohibit these harms, and our enforcement processes ensure that we apply these policies quickly, objectively and consistently to protect all members of our community. We take that responsibility seriously and are continuously working to improve and develop our safety approach.”

Hasan Piker was once suspended from Twitch for calling white people “Crackers.” HasanAbi/Youtube

Nevertheless, if Twitch does not act responsibly, Amazon must intervene. We are not optimistic.

Amazon employee Alexander ‘Sasha’ Troufanov has been held hostage in Gaza for more than a year and there is no evidence whatsoever that the tech giant has finished anything to get him released.

Gov. Gavin Newsom, California’s attorney general and legislature should investigate Twitch’s practices, including their boycott of Israel. The platform is based in California, where there is strong anti-BDS laws prohibit the state from doing business with companies with a policy “against . . . the nation and people of Israel.” Newsom could have a real impact here; the Golden State almost certainly did that contracts with Amazon Web Services.

Twitch says it has taken steps to address anti-Israel and anti-Semitic bias, but the results have yet to be seen.

Finally, Twitch’s Trust & Safety team needs to be overhauled. Oversight and management must take place domestically, and not, for example, in Egypt, where, according to an internal whistleblower, many staffers have lived and where a Pew poll shows found 95% of residents have a negative opinion about Jews. Hiring managers with deep-seated prejudices like Madzingira needs to be reconsidered.

There must be consequences for Twitch’s outrageous anti-Israel actions and proclamation of anti-Semitism. American society cannot thrive if our young generation is streamed to hate.

Liora Rez is the founder and executive director of Stop Anti-Semitism.