A Silent Voice is far superior to any of the best romantic animated films despite its overall reviews due to one key detail

Romance anime, whether in movie format or as a full-fledged anime, is always loved by fans. From A silent voice has The apothecary’s journals, there is an unlimited range of content available. There is something for everyone, especially when it comes to genre. This is not only limited to Shoujo but sometimes even Shonen. This gets fans of all preferences addicted to something or the other.

Among all the most memorable, some stand on a pedestal. Your lie in April, I want to eat your pancreas, Sasaki and Miyano, the list is endless and the praise is even more extensive. However, it is not abnormal to see fans competing against each other, notably in two cases; if they are covered in defects or if they are extremely publicized.

A silent voice against your name

The immense fame that Your name combined allowed it to become one of the best romantic animated films on the market. Usually, when works deal with heavy themes, they also manage to captivate audiences in distinctive ways. Both Your name And A silent voice dealt with different, albeit impactful, themes that are all too realistic in the real world.

Overall, due to its popularity, many would choose Makoto Shinkai’s work over another in a heartbeat. From an outside perspective, this would be understandable. The film is visually stunning and the story touches the heart deeply.

The music is also music that could lose anyone in its serenity. The plot has the ability to connect with fans because of its depth and emotion. However, this is not enough to consider it better than A silent voice.

The brand A silent voice left behind

There is a lot of criticism regarding A silent voice. Some would say it’s dull while others wouldn’t find it as appealing. It also deals with real-life struggles ranging from bullying to mental health to living as a disabled person. At the same time, there are many factors that cause the overall plot to be completely drowned out, especially with Shoya Ishida’s treatment of Shouko Nishimiya.

Despite its flaws, there is still something worth noting about the story, it is and was memorable. Compared to Your name, people would be more familiar with Naoko Yamada’s film. Whether because of its flaws or the plot, the impact was greater. Visually, Makoto Shinkai’s film would be leaps and bounds ahead.

From another point of view, it would be logical that A silent voice simply has a more memorable plot. Its complexity gives it the sensation of an onion with each layer revealing something new. This doesn’t mean either is bad. It’s simply that one tells the story better than the other. More importantly, it’s about what has the most impact, and for most fans, Yamada’s film is simply the way to go.

A silent voice And Your name are available to watch on Crunchyroll.