close
close

Sanctions resound after silent protest at Harvard Library

Sanctions resound after silent protest at Harvard Library

The board sets rules. Students, teachers destroyed them.

Regarding “Harvard suspends 25 teachers from the main library: After staging a demonstration criticizing the university’s ban on pro-Palestinian protesters” (Metro, October 26): The Globe reported on a group of Harvard faculty members who were banned by the university from using the main library for two weeks after a demonstration they held there. These faculties, in turn, had protested against a similar suspension of students who had organized a demonstration in another campus library.

The students and professors expressed their anger and disappointment that they had been sanctioned as a result of the demonstrations. However, the story made it clear that, according to administrators, the actions of both the students and professors “violated the rules and regulations regarding library use as specified in the university-wide Statement of Rights and Responsibilities.” So, as I understand it, those who have been suspended are angry because the university, after violating the rules against demonstrations in the library, has imposed a sanction.

There are good reasons to keep even silent demonstrations out of the library. Imagine if, instead of a pro-Palestinian message, protesters silently displayed signs equating abortion with murder. I wonder if the faculty member quoted in the article would defend these protesters by saying that “dissent should thrive in universities.”

Students and teachers can certainly choose to ignore the rules. They just shouldn’t be surprised that there are consequences.

Phyllis Schacht, Sharon

What’s next? A gag order for T-shirt messages?

It is almost unbelievable that professors would be denied access to a university library for displaying signs expressing political views. What’s next? Banning those who wear T-shirts or buttons in favor of their favorite candidate in the presidential election?

Felicia Nimue Ackerman, Providence

The writer is a professor of philosophy at Brown University.